Author Topic: Is Windows 7 Actually Faster Than Ubuntu 10.04? 2 of 2  (Read 1706 times)

Offline javajolt

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 36193
  • Gender: Male
  • I Do Windows
    • windows10newsinfo.com
Is Windows 7 Actually Faster Than Ubuntu 10.04? 2 of 2
« on: May 03, 2010, 10:43:15 PM »

continued for part 1


The Unigine Engine is rather fascinating as it's capable of delivering impressive graphics, their developers are rather friendly to Linux, and its the most demanding game engine that we have ever encountered for Linux (though soon it will need to compete with Valve's Source Engine running natively on Linux). We began using Unigine's oldest tech demo (Unigine Sanctuary) that is produced for Windows and Linux.


While by rather insignificant margins, Ubuntu 10.04 LTS was faster than Windows 7 in many cases. If you look at the results, where Ubuntu is pulling ahead is when the ATI Catalyst driver is being called into play with the Radeon/FirePro hardware. On the systems with NVIDIA graphics and their proprietary driver, its performance was usually slightly behind on Linux. The Intel Clarkdale graphics are not fast enough to handle the Unigine engine.


Next, we have Unigine Tropics, which was last year's tech demo from Unigine Corp. Again, when using ATI graphics, the performance was slightly faster under Ubuntu 10.04 but by no means significantly faster. With the NVIDIA GeForce 9800GTX setup using the Intel Core i7 setup, it was faster under Windows and in some cases by a number of frames.


The Unigine engine has OpenGL, DirectX 10.0, and DirectX 11.0 (with the Heaven benchmark and newer revisions of the engine) rendering support, but with our multi-platform testing
we are comparing just the OpenGL performance for obvious reasons.


Our last Unigine test is their newest Heaven benchmark. Unigine Heaven originally launched with the premiere of Microsoft Windows 7 as the first DirectX 11.0 capable benchmark, but the Linux version with the OpenGL 3.x renderer was not released until earlier this year when the benchmark hit version 2.0.


While Ubuntu with ATI graphics was normally faster than Windows 7 with the other Unigine tests, with Heaven it was in favor of Microsoft. However, the one exception is with the AMD Opteron setup and its ATI FirePro graphics where Ubuntu 10.04 narrowly beat out Windows 7.


Next was our X-Plane 9 testing courtesy of Laminar Research. As can be gathered from the results straight lines, this test is rather CPU limited with its high quality settings. Windows 7 x64 came out ahead when it was using NVIDIA graphics this time and ATI graphics in some instances. The Intel Linux driver could not handle running X-Plane 9.




For our final two tests we looked at the operating system performance in the OpenGL workstation benchmarks provided by SPECViewPerf 10.0. Sadly, on many of the consumer cards and drivers under Windows 7
, SPECViewPerf 10.0 could not run many of the view-sets. Oddly enough, even the octal-core Opteron workstation with the ATI FirePro V8800 would even lock-up under Windows 7 x64 when we tried to run these view-sets. The two systems that handled Maya fine for both operating systems were the AMD Athlon II X3 system with the Radeon HD 4670 graphics card and the Intel Core i7 system with the NVIDIA GeForce 9800GTX. The Linux results from the Phenom 9500 + Radeon HD 5770 and dual Opteron 2384 + FirePro V8800 were left in for reference numbers.

The Athlon II X3 system only was slightly in favor of Ubuntu 10.04 with SPEC's Maya view-set, but Ubuntu scored hugely with the NVIDIA graphics on the quad-core Core i7 system with Hyper Threading. In fact, Ubuntu 10.04 LTS was nearly twice as fast as Windows 7 on this system in this OpenGL workstation benchmark.


With the SolidWorks view-set provided by SPECViewPerf 10.0, the Athlon II X3 system this time was faster on Windows 7 x64. However, the Core i7 system with the NVIDIA GeForce 9800GTX consumer graphics card was still nearly twice as fast under the Linux operating system.


Well, that is part one of our Ubuntu 10.04 LTS vs. Windows 7 testing. As much as we would have liked to see Ubuntu's Lucid Lynx handily beat Windows 7, this was not the case, but to some extent the opposite. Windows 7 in some of the tests possessed definitive leads over Ubuntu 10.04 LTS with the OpenGL performance when using the proprietary ATI/AMD and NVIDIA graphics drivers, which have largely shared code-bases between Windows and Linux. Ubuntu 10.04 LTS also had its leads in some areas while in many of the tests the differences between the two operating systems were insignificant.

What these results do show is that Ubuntu 10.04 LTS "Lucid Lynx" is very capable of being a comparable gaming platform to Microsoft Windows at least as far as the quantitative performance is concerned. This is good news as Valve's Steam client and the Source Engine come to Linux and the first of the Unigine Engine games (likely Primal Carnage) are released. The exception to this, however, is if using Intel graphics. As these tests conclusively show, the Intel Linux graphics driver is no match to their Windows driver. The Intel Windows driver is significantly faster than the open-source Linux driver at this time, and with Intel's integrated graphics processors not being the best, every frame-rate really counts when it comes to making a game playable.

If switching from the proprietary ATI/NVIDIA Linux drivers to the open-source ATI/NVIDIA Linux drivers that are available, you too will take a performance hit, but at least the Radeon and Nouveau (NVIDIA) developers are embracing Gallium3D, which has shown to be faster than a classic Mesa driver like Intel's implementation. With ATI/NVIDIA hardware, you also have the choice of which driver to use, where as with Intel there is only one option and that is the driver that offers humiliating performance.

This article will also hopefully dispel all sorts of myths and FUD that has come up for both operating systems. Here's just a recent example that was mentioned on our Facebook page, "Linux drivers even proprietary ones have a long way to go, nvidia has improved vastly and ATI is still lagging far behind but none are close to their Windows equivalent, at least nvidia bought VDPAU which ATI is yet to implement, except for graphics, I expect Ubuntu to outscore Win7 on other tests."

More of the Windows 7 vs. Ubuntu 10.04 (and Mac OS X) tests will follow in the coming weeks for non-gaming areas. The Windows support upbringing will also allow us to closely compare and monitor the performance of Wine (the free software project that allows the running of many Windows binaries under Linux), which too will be coming soon and should be interesting. As work gets underway on these future articles, we invite your feedback in the Phoronix Forums (http://www.phoronix.com/forums/showthread.php?t=23555)(or also our IRC channel - #phoronix on FreeNode) on these results and what else you would like to see tested.

You can also reproduce these test results for yourself or run many other benchmarks all via the Phoronix Test Suite.

source:phoronix
end