Author Topic: AMD 2009 performance preview: taking Phenom II to 4.2GHz  (Read 944 times)

Offline riso

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 6406
  • Gender: Male
  • Beta tester Tech support dedicated 110%
    • windows 10 news and info | Forum - Blog
AMD 2009 performance preview: taking Phenom II to 4.2GHz
« on: November 10, 2009, 07:28:54 PM »
AMD's Phenom II quad-core parts launched to strong reviews last month, but will the architecture scale to provide continued competition for Intel's Nehalem? We decided to take one Phenom II, add freon, and overclock. Details inside.
When it launched in early January, Phenom II's sole purpose, its raison d'être, was to rejuvenate AMD's ability to compete against Intel with something other than price cuts. Viewed in aggregate, benchmarks of the new CPUs prove that Sunnyvale succeeded; the X4 940 and 920 are tough opponents in the mainstream quad-core market. I don't want to downplay this achievement; a strong Deneb launch was vital if AMD is to continue as a going concern. The problem is that Sunnyvale's future competition is locked, loaded, and launched. In the past, the question of whether AMD or Intel would hold a performance advantage "next time" was fueled by speculation and odd bits of data. In this case, Intel's "next-gen" design is already on the market and has been for several months. Nehalem is no paper tiger—it's here right now, and it'll hit the 940's current price point within 2009 (barring a major roadmap change). So can AMD scale Phenom II to match Nehalem? We wanted to find out, because the answer will tell us how the AMD vs. Intel battle will shape up in 2009. So, we took one Phenom II 940, added coolant, overclocked it to 4.2GHz, and ran the benchmarks listed below.

Cost comparison
We've known from the start that Phenom II would primarily target Core 2 Quad processors rather than Core i7. AMD definitely hit its target; Phenom II compares well against Intel's 45nm Yorkfield processors. A Phenom II X4 940 (3GHz) is currently $229 at Newegg while the Phenom II X4 920 (2.8GHz) is $195. Intel currently offers the Q9400 (2.66GHz, 6MB L2) at $229, the older 65nm Q6600 Kentsfield at 2.4GHz at $194.99, and the Q8300 (2.5GHz, 4MB L2) at $189.99. All of the Core i7 parts are significantly more expensive than the Phenom II X4 940; the Core i7 920 is $294.99 while the 940 is $565.


So how much bang does Phenom give for the buck?

Performance Summary
•Worldbench 6b2: Phenom II is more than adequate for any office or content creation work, but can't match Intel's Core i7-965 even when overclocked. Typically, however, these types of workloads don't require anything like ultra-powerful hardware.
•Photoshop CS4: Intel's Core i7-965 led our Photoshop benchmark with the overclocked Phenom II not far behind. The standard Phenom II trailed the pack, but again, all of the processors turned in good performance numbers.

•Handbrake 0.9.3: This x264 encoder scales well across all eight of Core i7's logical processors; Phenom II at 4.2GHz can't match the slower Core i7-920.

•Cinebench R10: Phenom II X4 940 is the slowest of the four cores we tested (though not by much), while the 4.2GHz flavor smashes everyone else in single-thread testing. Core i7-965 still wins the multi-threaded test, but our overclocked AMD chip makes Intel work for it.

•Valve Particle, Map Compilation Tests:Another set of overall wins for Intel; Phenom II 4.2GHz can't quite match the Core i7-920. Phenom II X4 940 at stock speeds is at the back of the pack.
•Crysis: Phenom II is an excellent gaming chip. The X4 940 beats the Core i7-920 here while the 4.2GHz chip is only a hair back from the Core i7-965.
•Call of Duty 4: This is one game that's quite fond of Phenom II; the Phenom II X4 940 at 4.2GHz wins the benchmark with the stock-clocked flavor in a tie for second.
•Unreal Tournament 3: In UT3, our overclocked chip leads the rest; the standard X4 940 still outperforms Intel's Core i7-920.
•Assassin's Creed: Another game, another good showing from AMD. Our overclocked Phenom II outperforms the Core i7-965 while the Phenom II X4 940 is again well ahead of the Core i7-920.
AMD's Phenom II X4 940 doesn't lead a majority of our tests at stock speeds, but both the Core i7-920 and the Core 2 Quad Q9650 are significantly more expensive than the AMD part. The Core i7-920 is a bit better in that regard, but LGA1366 motherboards and DDR3 still command a price premium over AM2+ and DDR2.

AMD's new chip competes well against the Intel parts it's priced against, has plenty of overclocking headroom even if you don't have a phase-changer handy, and offers excellent gaming performance. Compared to the Phenom that proceeded it, Phenom II is a slam dunk. Whether or not that's enough to save AMD, particularly in the current economic climate, is regrettably an open question