Author Topic: First look: Microsoft Security Essentials impresses  (Read 1125 times)

Offline javajolt

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 36193
  • Gender: Male
  • I Do Windows
    • windows10newsinfo.com
First look: Microsoft Security Essentials impresses
« on: September 29, 2009, 06:16:30 PM »

Microsoft's new antimalware solution, Microsoft Security Essentials, is now available for Windows XP, Windows Vista, and Windows 7. Ars puts MSE through its paces and finds an unobtrusive app with a clean interface that protected us in the dark corners of the Internet.


After a short three-month beta program, Microsoft is officially releasing Microsoft Security Essentials (MSE), its free, real-time consumer antimalware solution for fighting viruses, spyware, rootkits, and Trojans. MSE is yet another layer of defense the company is offering to help its customers fight the threats that plague Windows PCs.

Microsoft Security Essentials is available for Windows XP 32-bit (8.61MB), Windows Vista/7 32-bit (4.28MB), and Windows Vista/7 64-bit (4.71MB). The final build number is 1.0.1611.0. Microsoft warns that MSE should not be installed alongside any other antimalware application. Indeed, MSE's installer disables Windows Defender completely, which makes sense as it is a sort of superset to Windows Defender. It builds upon Windows Defender by offering both real-time protection and on-demand scanning for all types of malware.

Although you won't be asked for personal information or to register for anything, you'll need to pass the Windows Genuine Advantage validation to install MSE. In short, while Microsoft's security updates are available for free to pirates, active protection from Redmond isn't.

One might notice the "Essentials" branding that Microsoft is clearly pulling from Windows Live Essentials. MSE won't be included in WLE, however, even though non-Windows Live applications like Silverlight are included in the suite. Furthermore, there is no download link for MSE included in the final release of Windows 7, but there is for Windows Live Essentials. This is a curious decision given that Redmond wants to push MSE out to all those who currently do not have a security solution (between 50 and 60 percent of Windows users, according to the company). Nevertheless, it can be quite easily explained: Microsoft wants to avoid antitrust issues from competing security giants.

Now that you've got the necessary background information, let's take a closer at the different features of MSE

The GUI

Microsoft Security Essentials has one of the simplest and clearest GUIs we've seen for an antimalware solution. This is not something we would call "obtrusive" or "bloated" like many of the security products currently on the market. It may not be the most elegant design, but that's not what one should be looking for in a security solution anyway. An antimalware solution needs to clearly communicate important information when you're using it; barring a need for user response, it should make itself scarce.


When everything is running as it should, MSE makes sure users know all is well, with a green-colored highlighting across the UI and via a green taskbar icon.


When something is amiss, MSE makes sure users know they'll need to take action, with red-color highlighting across the UI and via a red taskbar icon.



Microsoft Security Essentials updates itself very quietly in the background. In fact, we were never once bothered by its updating system; the only prompts we received were when the application actually needed our attention, like when it detected a threat that needed to be cleaned. Signatures are updated more or less daily through Microsoft Update, though new signatures can be published as often as three times a day. The core antimalware engine is scheduled to update itself with new features and bug fixes on a monthly basis.


The History tab is useful for reviewing how well the program is working, and tweaking decisions you've already made on previous detections. It gives a great overview of what the program has found and also gives more information on each potential threat.


MSE has a surprising number of settings to work with. Considering the simplicity of the product, it's still very customizable. Power users enjoy having tons of features to tweak, and we think they'll be satisfied with the settings that can be changed in MSE. It doesn't offer as many options as some other security suites, but given its features, the settings that can be adjusted are exactly what one would expect.

Detection

MSE is the first Microsoft security product to make use of the company's new Dynamic Signature Service (DSS); the next version of Forefront will also use DSS. When MSE detects that a file is making suspicious actions (such as unexpected network connections, attempting to modify privileged parts of the system, or downloading known malicious content) and it has no virus signature for it, MSE will send a profile of the suspected malware to Microsoft's servers. If there is a new signature for it, one that has yet to be sent out to the MSE client, MSE will be told how to clean the file. In this way, DSS helps ensure users stay protected by the most current virus definitions available without having to wait for the next scheduled download. Still, this communication will only occur for malware that is not in the current signatures.


The EICAR Standard Anti-Virus Test File is a simple file, developed by the European Institute for Computer Antivirus Research, to allow people, companies, and programmers to test their antivirus programs without having to use a real computer virus. Every single antimalware product in the market can detect the EICAR test file, and given that MSE officially launches today, we wanted to make sure it would at least past the most basic test. It can. The top window is the prompt you get when you try to download the file and the second one you get after you hit the "Clean computer" button.


The above threat was detected while we were browsing the darker corners of the Web with Internet Explorer. We didn't notice anything odd until MSE told us it had found something and needed our single-click to confirm that we wanted it to finish its job. It did, and we continued merrily onwards, virus-free.

As we continued testing MSE, it either caught threats after they were downloaded and executed, or blocked them from getting onto the computer in the first place. It doesn't have a 100 percent detection rate (that would be impossible, of course), but when we uninstalled it and scanned our machine with various other third-party software, they all came up with nothing. Based on our findings, MSE was definitely doing its job well while we were using it. Once security research companies pit the product against millions of malware samples, we'll be able to draw better conclusions.

Performance and unobtrusiveness

It should be noted that MSE is very small; the installer sizes range from just over 4MB to under 9MB. The installation is also very quick and the program's folder takes up only about 13MB. MSE sports a single tray icon (hidden by default in Windows 7) that indicates it is running. The software doesn't add any browser toolbars, desktop gadgets, or additional bloatware during installation. The small footprint of the product is also evident when looking at the system requirements:

•For Windows XP, a PC with a CPU with clock speed of at least 500MHz and at least 256MB of RAM

•For Windows Vista and Windows 7, a PC with a CPU with clock speed of at least 1.0GHz and at least 1GB of RAM

•VGA (display): 800x600 or higher

•Storage: 140MB of available hard-disk space

•An Internet connection is required for installation and to download the latest virus and spyware definitions.

Microsoft claims it designed MSE to run quietly in the background, only alerting users when there is an action for them to take, while at the same time limiting CPU and memory usage. The company includes three features in MSE to keep it light: CPU throttling (the system will remain responsive to the user's tasks), idle-time scanning (scans and updates use a low-priority thread and only run when the PC is idle), and smart caching and active memory swapping (virus signatures not in use are not loaded into memory).

Our tests were in line with Redmond's assertions: although we saw an odd CPU spike or two, overall the product performed exceptionally well and was very ninja-like. It never bothered us unnecessarily; updates and scans were all done silently in the background. Not only did we not see them being performed, but the actual tasks did not result in slower system performance. Beyond finding threats, if any other problems were discovered, MSE used Windows notifications to alert the user via the Security Center in XP/Vista, and the Action Center in Windows 7.

Conclusion

We liked Windows Live OneCare, but the only thing that we found truly differentiating about the product was that it came with three licenses for a single low price. That was a refreshing move for the security suite market, but it definitely wasn't enough to push OneCare ahead of the competition. While OneCare offered a Managed Firewall, PC Performance Tuning, Data Backup and Restore, Multi-PC Management, and Printer Sharing, MSE is really closer to Forefront Client Security, Microsoft's antivirus product for the enterprise.

In fact, the same engine is used for of the company's security products, including MSE, Forefront, and the Microsoft Malicious Software Removal Tool. Engine updates for MSE and Forefront are delivered at the same time, while signature updates, on the other hand, can be delivered at different times and frequencies compared to Microsoft's other security software. Microsoft expects the use of MSE will significantly improve Forefront since the data the company gets from additional users will be able to improve both products.

Although MSE might not boast as many features as OneCare did, it is a lot better at what it does do. It's free, and it requires no registration, trial versions, or license renewals. It really does automatically stay up-to-date. Most core functions can be activated with a single click. It is also very lightweight.

Based on what we've seen so far, we have to recommend that you at least give the product a download. Everyone currently using free antimalware software should give it a shot, and those with paid solutions should think about taking MSE for a spin before renewing subscriptions.

source:aretechnica