SSDs are so new that we will not see real-world lifespans and reliability tests for a good bit. I would hope that they would be better than HDD but you never know.
SSDs are more reliable than hard disks, and should last a good 20 years at least not counting performance degradation. If you're looking towards and SSD to be comprable to regualar HDD, odds are no. Are they fast and oh so wonderful? Yes. But if you're looking to buy an SSD now and hope for reliability, I'm afraid their track record isn't so good for now. Give them a few quarters/years and SSDs will eventually replace the old platter hard drives, but it won't happen for a while.
The answer to your other question of similar reliability level among SSD manufacturers is a resounding "No!". SSD manufacturers find various ways to cut costs by using cheaper NAND chips, controllers, QC process. Go for brand names like OCZ, Intel and Samsung - they are so far considered the most reliable on the SSD list.
SSDs are shock proof which itself puts them lightyears ahead of any platter hard disk.
Here's a statistic for the average lifespan of various data storage media:
platter hard disks: 3-6 yrs
magnetic tape: 10-20 yrs
floppy disks: 1-5 years (sometimes only a matter of hours

)
optical disks: 10-100 yrs
static memory (such as SSDs): 50-100 yrs
stone tablets: up to 10.000 yrs