Powercolor Radeon HD 5970 2GB
ATI launched their Radeon 5870, the world’s first DirectX11 graphics card to great critical acclaim. Shortly after this they brought to market two great mainstream cards in the form of the 5750 and 5770 which gave us price and performance similar to the older 4800 series but with additional/enhanced features, lower temperatures and more desirable power requirements.
With those products ATI have a very impressive set of high end and mainstream cards which currently have no direct competition from Nvidia due to their delay in getting DX11 products to market. This may change shortly but in the mean time ATI are now making an attempt to take a stranglehold on the enthusiast market with the release of their high end Radeon 5970.
We are taking a closeup look at the Powercolor HD 5970 2GB and putting it through its paces in a selection of real world gaming tests, including the recently released Modern Warfare 2. In addition to this we will cover GPU computing and high definition playback as well as having a play with an official ATI voltage tweaking tool. This little application may well make this product a favourite with enthusiasts who want to get the most from their purchase.
We pick up where we left off on benchmarking this amazing Graphics Card.
There are some good gains in performance moving from a single 5870 GPU to the 5970 and these actually take the game from being stuttery to completely smooth when playing at 1920x1200 with enthusiast settings. When looking at the detailed fps graph it is also possible to see that the game spends a lot of time up at 50 on the 5970 which gives us our average performance of 47, an exceptional result which is 10 frames per second above the last generation’s multi-GPU setup.
Blu-Ray playback is a relatively simple affair on ATI and Nvidia hardware, just install the latest drivers. Tweak the display settings to the preferred level and then run PowerDVD 9 which features Pure-Video and Avivo acceleration. Through these technologies the graphics cards are able to take the video workload away from the CPU leaving it free to perform other tasks.
As the results show, when using a high bitrate AVC movie ATI have a small advantage over Nvidia in Blu-Ray playback however the gap is closing all the time and it is now near impossible to tell the difference in graphs, let alone real world use.
MKV playback is a little more complicated. To gain video acceleration on this format with ATI cards we need to perform some configuration on Media Player Classic. With the tweaks in place the CPU usage statistic is on average less than 10 percent. The Nvidia side of MKV playback is a little easier to use. Through purchasing CoreCodec we are able to play back MKV content in numerous different players by simply ticking a box in the codec options. In addition to being easier and more flexible the performance is also better on Nvidia with the CPU use never rising above 8%.
GPU Computing - Video Encoding
GPU computing is something which is fast becoming a very important feature on “video” cards. Nvidia and their partners have released a number of useful utilities for CUDA enabled cards which all help to enhance the performance of day to day tasks. One such program is Badaboom, a small utility which allows us to convert content from one video format to another with assistance from the GPU. Nvidia are not on their own in this area though as ATI have their own application for video conversion, Avivo Video Convertor which is bundled with their drivers and is free.
Using Badaboom and Avivo Video Convertor we converted a short AVI file to the best quality IPod format in each application.
When converting video to a format better suited for the iPod we see that ATI finish the conversion two seconds behind Nvidia for this clip. If we were to use a longer sample clip the performance gap would increase and so it is more desirable to use Nvidia hardware for this type of test, though both sets of hardware would still complete the task faster than a CPU on its own.
NOTE: From viewing the files created by the applications the general consensus in the office was that the quality of both was excellent and perfectly watchable with the Nvidia video appearing very slightly less compressed.GPU Computing - DVD Upscaling
It is fair to say that many of the people reading this article will have a substantial collection of DVDs and that many will not have been replaced by a Blu-Ray version at this time. It is however more than likely the case that these movies will be watched on a screen (monitor or HDTV) which is capable of much higher resolution than DVDs provide. In this scenario it is important to have quality upscaling software and recently Cyberlink released PowerDVD 9 which includes just that. Even better though is the fact that it supports GPU acceleration for ATI and Nvidia hardware.
Before we discuss the results it is worth taking into account two points about DVD upscaling. The first is that our performance figures are taken from a Core-i7 CPU. In this task it doesn’t really get faster than that and so the CPU only performance is quite low. The lower specification the processor, the more impressive the GPU assisted gains will be. The second point is that the appearance of the upscaled content will vary greatly depending on the hardware used, including aspects such as the size/resolution of the screen. We shouldn’t expect to see excellent results on a 2560x1600 screen; 720p and 1080p models can show desirable results though. And one other point... upscaled DVD will never look as good as Blu-Ray.
In this test both ATI and Nvidia show us impressive performance however the Radeon just edges out the GeForce.
Temperatures and Overclocking
ATI’s X2 cards have been well known for their high temperatures and noise levels and when we read the product information for this card it seemed this situation would be dramatically improved thanks to the use of a vapor chamber cooler. To a limited extent it has, gone are temperatures over 90c with the maximum on this card being 86c which is acceptable for a reference card.
Where we do have issue is the noise level required to achieve this. At 40% the fan becomes noticeable and anything over 50% is intrusive and distracting so when the card hits 59% it requires a pair of headphones or loud desktop speakers to ensure the gaming experience is not impacted.
It is very rare when either ATI or Nvidia launch a new product to make a big deal of overclocking potential in the press information however that is exactly what ATI did with the 5970.
The press PDF’s contained several bullet points early on and then four pages dedicated to advertising the overclocking potential later on. When we then see that our sample achieved a core overclock of 215MHz it seems that ATI were right to emphasise the potential, although there is one caveat. The GPU’s used on this card are basically underclocked 5870s which usually run at 850MHz so really the overclock is 90MHz ... this is still quite good but not as impressive as first glance. Memory overclock was also good, although our test sample didn’t hit the levels we had hoped based on the PDFs.
This maximum overclock of 940/1260 was achieved using the ATI Voltage tool which allows us to increase the core to 1.1625v from 1.05v and memory from 1.1v to 1.15v. At stock voltage our card achieved 890/1245.
To test the effect of the overclock on our card we ran through our Modern Warfare 2 test again. Here are the results.
Conclusion
When looking at the 5970 there is one issue we need to get out of the way first, the name the company have chosen to use. As a whole AMD are a nightmare for over complicating their product naming conventions for consumers ... releasing Athlon’s that would be better called Phenom’s or chipsets where a higher model number doesn’t necessarily mean better features or improved performance.
Until now ATI cards have been unaffected by this ... consumers know and understand the X2 brand, they get that it is a dual GPU product just by seeing the text. Removing the X2 doesn’t allow AMD/ATI to correctly identify the main feature of the product to consumers; in fact it is a pretty nonsensical model number because if anything 5890 would be more appropriate.
The ability to effectively market a product really only affects AMD/ATI, for consumers the negative aspects of the card are actually hardware related. A 12 inch PCB is pushing the limits of acceptability in our opinion and while it is usually desirable to have a product with a single PCB it does open up debate on whether this is a card where using two PCB’s would have been more desirable for consumers. This really will be a product which limits the choice of chassis used.
Noise is also an issue with the 5970; at idle it is very quiet and runs at a reasonable temperature thanks to excellent power saving technology within the card which keeps the draw at a maximum of 42w. Under load we really do need the vapor chamber cooler as even with a fan speed of 59% the card becomes clearly audible.
It really is about time that ATI, a company who are capable of creating some of the most complex components on the market start to utilize a dedicated engineering team whose sole purpose is to design an effective, low noise cooler design - we implore ATI to ditch those tiny red fans or use more than one and spin them slower, it really isn’t rocket science guys. The fact that most ATI partners use the ill equipped reference cooler affects a considerable number of consumers. We hope Powercolor and Sapphire will release modified versions of this card with improved cooling in the near future.
this is the current card and the front mounted cooling system A DH mockup of a rear mounted heatpipe design to aid the single fanAdding an extra fan and spinning both slower really would help this card (and the user) in
the long run - if adjustments could be make to the dimensions of the mounted vapor chamber
That is not to say that the 5970 is disappointing in its current form. Far from it, gaming with this monster is a fantastic experience. In everything but Crysis Warhead we were able to play at 2560x1600 and often with 8x anti-aliasing. It is hard to push a card any harder than that and few end users have screens which are even capable of such a resolution. For anyone on 1680x1050, 1920x1080 or 1920x1200 the 5970 will handle anything thrown at it, regardless of the settings.
ATI don’t yet have a range of GPU computing applications available on their cards to match Nvidia’s but when we are able to make comparisons (such as video conversions) we see that the performance of the 5970 is good. The more applications ATI can produce, or assist companies in producing the more consumers will benefit in this area. It is also great to see that the excellent Blu-Ray performance of the Radeon range continues with this hardware and that the support for 7.1 audio, including DTS Master Audio and Dolby TrueHD is also present.
Summary:
It may be big and it may be noisy but the 5970 is a great card and once companies such as Sapphire and PowerColor work their magic on the cooling system it will be near perfect. We can’t wait to try the big upcoming DirectX 11 titles such as Dirt 2 and Alien vs. Predator on the 5970, as things stand it will be an experience which is unmatched. If they had spent some time with the cooling solution it would be worthy of our GOLD award but as it stands we will need to wait on third party cooling solutions for the card to be worthy of this acclaim. You can chalk up another success for ATI however, this is without a doubt the fastest card on the market right now.