Author Topic: Microsoft Security Essentials  (Read 860 times)

Offline riso

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 6406
  • Gender: Male
  • Beta tester Tech support dedicated 110%
    • windows 10 news and info | Forum - Blog
Microsoft Security Essentials
« on: October 14, 2009, 10:41:19 AM »
It's called Microsoft Security Essentials - and it really means bare essentials. Not that we expected the moon on a stick, considering the package and updates are completely free, but next to commercial security suites the feature set looks laughably thin. There's no firewall, no web protection, no email scanner and precious few user settings. But although malware can arrive from many directions, it almost invariably works by dropping a malicious executable onto your PC, and that's where Security Essentials focuses. It examines files on access to intercept malware before it can launch, and for extra security it will also run more extensive scans to a user-defined schedule. It's the oldest approach in the book, but it should cut off most attacks so long as the malware database is up to scratch. And, happily, in our tests Security Essentials picked up 96% of our sample malware, putting it on a par with respectable commercial packages such as F-Secure Internet Security 2010.

Thanks to Security Essentials' limited remit it's very simple to use, presenting only a clean four-tabbed window and a system tray icon. And it has relatively little impact on your system resources. Installing it on our Vista test system increased idle RAM usage from 499MB up to just 583MB - 3MB below our A-Listed Avira Premium Security Suite.


"False sense of security"
Read how a defensive Symantec was quick to pour cold water on Microsoft's free product.Boot time was entirely unaffected by the software, and we saw a mere extra seven seconds of CPU activity after the desktop appeared. This was considerably less than the 15 seconds incurred by Avira, though of course Avira has many more components to initialise.

We have some nagging doubts about Security Essentials' ability to cope with the newest and most aggressive threats. It remains to be seen how the package will cope with rootkit-type exploits that run parts of the OS in a virtual environment.

And, since database updates come down through Windows Update, it could take weeks for you to receive protection against new threats. The likes of F-Secure and Trend Micro, by contrast, couple behavioural analysis with online databases that are instantly updated as new signatures are created.

For that reason we hesitate to recommend you abandon a paid-for security suite in favour of Security Essentials. But, if you have a machine that's currently without security software - whether for reasons of performance or price - installing Security Essentials should be a no-brainer. Indeed, there's no longer any excuse for running an unprotected machine, and that alone should make Security Essentials a huge success
Verdict
Far from a comprehensive security suite, but it's free, simple, light - and impressively effective

Review Date: 13 Oct 2009