Author Topic: Toshiba HG2 43nm 256GB Solid State Drive Review 1 of 1  (Read 1756 times)

Offline javajolt

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 36193
  • Gender: Male
  • I Do Windows
    • windows10newsinfo.com
Toshiba HG2 43nm 256GB Solid State Drive Review 1 of 1
« on: February 27, 2010, 06:44:03 AM »

Toshiba's 43nm HG2 SSD

Legit Reviews has done dozens of solid-state drive (SSD) reviews over the past year, but they have all been on retail drives. When Toshiba contacted LR and asked us if we would be willing to do a review on their 43m HG2 series 2.5" MLC NAND-based SSD for them we were a little thrown off at first, but we figured we'd give it our best. Our thoughts on this is that Toshiba is one of the major players in the SSD industry and they have had a number of key design wins in the market place when it comes to SSDs. We've opened up SSDs in recent months that were branded with other companies names only to find them being re-branded Toshiba drives. This is a chance to look at the original drive, so why not go for it!



Toshiba's HG2 SSDs have been, up to this point, available to OEMs only and are available in capacities of 64GB, 128GB, 256GB and 512GB, in 1.8-inch or 2.5-inch drive enclosures. The Toshiba HG2 43nm series of SSDs are targeted for use in notebook computers and gaming or home entertainment systems. In another word, this is a mainstream SSD that is aimed at the consumer market and not the enterprise space.

Toshiba's own 43nm multi-channel MLC controller is used in conjunction with Toshiba MLC NAND for a maximum sequential read speed of 230MBps and maximum sequential write speed of 180MBps. A proprietary wear leveling algorithm optimizes the performance, reliability and lifetime of the drive.

The HG2 drive series also supports the TRIM command, which is one of the most desired features to have on an SSD now that Windows 7 has been released. The TRIM Command allows an operating system, such as Windows 7, to send information to a solid state drive controller to tell it which data blocks are no longer in use and can be deleted. An OS operation such as delete in the past or with operating systems that don't support the TRIM command means the data blocks involved are flagged as not in use but not actually deleted. TRIM allows the OS to pass this information on down to the SSD controller, so the data is removed before the next time the drive may need to write to those blocks. The purpose of the instruction is to maintain the speed of the SSD throughout its lifespan, avoiding the slowdown that early models encountered once all of the cells had been written to once.



Flipping the Toshiba HG2 SSD over we find the full part number for our 256GB SSD that we will be benchmarking today. That part number would be THN2256GG8BBAA, which tells you that this is a HG2 43nm 2.5" OEM SSD. The drive has the usual threaded mounting holes on both the bottom and sides to fit in various cases and laptops.

Toshiba HG2 SSD Product Specifications:

Size: 69.9 x 9.5 x 100 mm

Weight: 66g

Interface: Serial ATA-2 (3Gbps)

Voltage 5V

Maximum Sequential Read Speed - 230MB/s

Maximum Write Speed - 180MB/s

Temperature Range: 0 to 70 Degrees Celsius

MTTF: 1 Million Hours



Here is a better look at the Serial ATA (SATA) II header, SATA power connector and the jumper that is needed for firmware flashing. The SATA II 3Gbps storage interface is backwards-compatible with SATA I and also works on SATA III 6Gbps headers as well.

Inside The Toshiba HG2 SSD

Since we have never seen what components are being used inside the Toshiba HG2 SSD we opened up our 256GB drive to see what the internals look like.



After removing the four Philips head screws that hold down the SSD cover plate we were able to lift it off and see what we have inside. With the cover removed we see a bare PCB, but it looks familiar. One very interesting thing was noticed once we opened up the SSD, and that is the fact that a thermal pad is placed between the metal casing and the components on the PCB. This helps transfer the heat away from the components, which helps keep them cool and the large metal casing acts like a heat spreader. This is something we have only seen on the second generation Kingston SSDNow V+ Series SSDs (SNV325-S2) that we reviewed a month ago to the day. It would appear that Kingston Technology sources the parts for their latest V+ series SSDs from Toshiba, so this drive should be identical.



Removing the PCB from the housing and flipping it over we can see Toshiba MLC NAND Flash memory chips, a Toshiba controller and a Micron DRAM IC that serves as a cache chip.The eight double stacked TH58NVG7D7EBAK0 MLC NAND Flash memory chips that are being used on the drive.

This drive with these chips is pretty much bullet proof as it has an operating vibrating tolerance of 2.7G! The non-operating vibration tolerance is 20G, which is amazing when you think about how much force that would be.



The heart and soul of the drive would be the Toshiba T6UG1XBG SSD controller pictured above. This controller is manufactured on the 43nm process and includes all the latest features like native TRIM support. Sitting next to the controller on the left hand side is a single 128MB Micron 9LA17-D9HSJ DDR DRAM module that is used for cache, which helps improve the drive's performance.

Toshiba says that this configuration on their 43nm HG2 drives have a sequential read speed of up to 230MB/s and up to 180MB/s on the maximum sequential write speed.

The Test System



Before we look at the numbers, here is a brief glance at the test system that was used. All testing was done on a fresh install of Windows 7 Ultimate 64-bit. All benchmarks were completed on the desktop with no other software programs running. The Intel Core i7 test system was run in triple-channel memory mode at 1600MHz with 8-8-8-24 memory timings. The ASUS P6X58D Premium motherboard was run using all the latest drives and BIOS 0702. The ASUS P6X58D Premium motherboard uses the Intel ICH10R south bridge chipset, which we used to run our 'boot drive'.  The boot drive used in our test system was an Intel X25-V 40GB model with TRIM enabled. We then used the Marvell 9123 PCIe SATA 6Gbps controller that is on the motherboard to test the SSDs that are used in the benchmark charts. All of the SSDs were tested in a fresh out of the box (FOB) state and the system had the latest firmware installed on it when testing was done.



The Marvell 9123 SATA 6G Controller was tested using driver version 1.0.0.1031 or 1031 for short.  This driver is said to be the first Marvell driver able to pass the TRIM command from Windows to the drives.



SSDs Included in the Benchmarking:

Crucial RealSSD C300 256GB - Firmware 0001

OCZ Vertex 2 Pro 100GB - Firmware 232A11F0

OCZ Vertex LE 100GB - Firmware 1.0

OCZ Vertex 120GB - Firmware 1.5

Intel X25-M G2 160GB  - Firmware 02HD

Toshiba THNS256GG8BBA 256GB - Firmware AGYA0201

Detailed Information on the Toshiba THNS256GG8BBA 256GB SSD:


http://i45.tinypic.com/2v1l10y.jpg

The Toshiba SSD operates on the ATA8 standard and has features like S.M.A.R.T. and  APM (Advanced Power Management) according to Crystal Disk Info.

HD Tach v3.0.4.0

HD Tach is a low level hardware benchmark for random access read/write storage devices such as hard drives, removable drives (ZIP/JAZZ), flash devices, and RAID arrays. HD Tach uses custom device drivers and other low level Windows interfaces to bypass as many layers of software as possible and get as close to the physical performance of the device as possible.


http://i47.tinypic.com/10y3rya.jpg

Benchmark Results: The Toshiba HG2 256GB SSD was able to reach 221.8MB/s read and 34.5MB/s write. Something strange is going on with the write score, and due to the fact that HD Tach has not been updated in some time we will be ignoring that performance score. The random access time and CPU utilization were really low, which is what we like to see on SSDs.



Comparison Chart: Compared to other popular SSDs the Toshiba HG2 256GB SSD performed well for a mainstream drive, but below many of the other high-end enthusiast grade SSDs that we have benchmarked on the same test system. 

HD Tune v4.01

HD Tune Pro 4.01 is an extended version of HD Tune which includes many new features such as write benchmark, secure erasing, AAM setting, folder usage view, disk monitor, command line parameters and file benchmark.


http://i45.tinypic.com/ekp8o0.jpg


http://i46.tinypic.com/29c0u90.jpg

Benchmark Results: The Toshiba HG2 256GB SSD had solid performance numbers in HD Tune Pro 4.01 on both the read test and the write tests. The average read speed was found to be 210MB/s with an average write speed of 171MB/s.  The read test had an access time of 0.1ms, while the write test had an access time of 0.3ms.



Comparison Chart: When comparing the Toshiba HG2 256GB SSD to the competition, it had an average read speed just behind the OCZ Vertex 2 Pro and Vertex LE 100GB SSDs. The average write speed was 171MB/s, which was enough to out-perform the Intel X250M Gen 2 160GB SSD. The burst rate of 212MB/s was also ahead of the Intel mainstream SSD, but behind the other drives we tested it against. 

64MB File Test


http://i49.tinypic.com/2076zv7.jpg

Benchmark Results: Running the built-in file benchmark test in HD Tune 4.01 showed once again just how the drive performs with various file sizes. This test shows the Toshiba HG2 256GB SSD topping out at nearly 225MB/sec in the read test and 155MB/sec in the write test.

HD Tune v4.01 - Random Access

The random access read and write test is a very important performance area to look at on solid state drives as some controllers have problems with random writes. In recent years the controllers have improved and the firmware has been better optimized for random read and write performance.

Random Access Read Test Results:


http://i49.tinypic.com/2mfnfyh.jpg

Benchmark Results: When it comes to the random access read performance test the Toshiba HG2 256GB SSD drive did fairly well with solid average access times and what we would call mainstream performance in both IOPS and MB/s.   The 4KB speed on the Toshiba HG2 256GB SSD was 28MB/s, which wasn't that far behind the Crucial RealSSD C300 256GB as it had an average speed of 31.5MB/s while the Vertex LE was at 33.4MB/s. 

When it comes to operations per second (IOPS) the Toshiba HG2 256GB SSD had 7164 IOPS at 4KB, which is close to the 8079 IOPS on the C300 and 8752 IOPS that the Vertex LE. As good as these scores sound the Intel X25-M G2 160GB drive had 16021 IOPS in the 4KB read test and is still the drive to beat when it comes to small read file size tests.

Random Access Write Test Results:


http://i50.tinypic.com/2j7i8k.jpg

Benchmark Results: The write performance test results of the Toshiba HG2 256GB SSD were solid looking once again at 14.3MB/s. It should be pointed out that the Crucial RealSSD C300 256GB was able to reach 10MB/s read on the 4KB write tests, so this drive actually beat the mighty SATA 6Gbps SSD! 

4KB Random Write File Test Results Chart:



Benchmark Results: Many of our readers have asked for a chart showing side-by-side comparisons of the drives we have tested in the 4KB random access write test. You can see from this chart that the Toshiba HG2 256GB SSD was far from leading the charts, but it wasn't at the bottom either.

continued