Author Topic: Windows 7 and Snow Leopard - year of the glorified Service Pack?  (Read 813 times)

Offline javajolt

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 36193
  • Gender: Male
  • I Do Windows
    • windows10newsinfo.com
Windows 7 and Snow Leopard - year of the glorified Service Pack?
« on: September 04, 2009, 06:31:39 PM »

Look in the Leopard's eye!


It seems less is more when it comes to new operating systems.

You could be mistaken for thinking Windows 7 and Snow Leopard are little more than re-plumbing and bug fixes with a splash of new eye candy. Both Microsoft and Apple have gone out of their way to emphasise that their new operating systems are more about optimising what we've already got rather than offering new flagship features. Snow Leopard's pricing, and even the very name, suggests that it's designed to be a refresh for Leopard rather than a completely new cat.

When it comes to under the bonnet changes, Snow Leopard is clearly far more than a service pack. Grand Central Dispatch lets Snow Leopard make better use of multi-core processing while OpenCL lets it leverage the power of the NVIDIA graphics chip. Several applications have also been updated to 64-bit. Apple is basically rebuilding the foundations of Mac OSX in order to prepare for the future. Windows 7 has also been optimised compared to Vista and, unlike Vista, generally shouldn't require a new PC. Most of Windows 7's new features are designed for business users. Windows 7 is a far more enticing upgrade for XP users - for example it has a lot of security features baked in that were only bolted onto Windows XP with SP2, but tones down the over-zealous alerts that plague Vista.

Both operating systems are promising to let you squeeze more from your existing hardware while maintaining backwards compatibility with your software and peripherals. Bad news if you're a PC or chip maker, but good news if you're a consumer or business running on a lean budget.

I think maybe that's the key here, both Apple and Microsoft realise that - in the current economic climate - their key message needs to focus on value for money. You can see similar messages popping up in a lot of advertising - there's one bus stop poster around claiming that "saving is the new spending". Perhaps mathematically impossible, but you can see what they're trying to say.

The key difference between Redmond and Cupertino's approaches to this year's updates is pricing. At $39 the upgrade from Leopard to Snow Leopard is a no-brainer, although you might want to check that all your important applications are Snow Leopard-compatible before you take the plunge. Apple is encouraging Tiger users on Intel hardware to buy the $229 upgrade pack, which includes the latest versions of iWork and iLife, but it features exactly the same Snow Leopard installer disc as the $39 pack.

Meanwhile Microsoft is still charging top dollar for Windows 7, even if you suffered through Vista's long teething period. It costs $199, $399 and $429 respectively to upgrade Vista or XP to Windows 7 Home Premium, Professional and Ultimate. If you want to buy Windows 7 from scratch, you’re looking at $299 for Home Premium, $449 for Professional and $469 for Ultimate. That's not cheap.

As a show of good faith, I reckon Vista users should be allowed to upgrade to Windows 7 for $39. As it is, if you're happily running XP or Vista there's little incentive to rush out and spend hundreds of dollars on Windows 7 straight away. Rather than go through the expense, hassle and perhaps pain of upgrading your computer, just wait until you buy your next computer. I'd say the same thing about Snow Leopard if Apple was charging $399 to upgrade rather than $39.

When you do buy your next PC, I'd certainly embrace Windows 7 rather than asking for a downgrade to XP as many people have done to avoid Vista. I certainly wouldn't recommend skipping Windows 7 and waiting for its sucessor. Still, that doesn't mean you should blow away a perfectly good OS and pay top dollar to upgrade on day one.