Windows News and info 15th Anniversary 2009-2024

Other Operating Systems => Fixes => Windows 7 All => Windows 7 | Windows 9 => Hardware => Topic started by: javajolt on November 19, 2009, 02:40:58 AM

Title: Close Up Look At The Radeon 5870 Part 1
Post by: javajolt on November 19, 2009, 02:40:58 AM

(http://i46.tinypic.com/98x8hy.jpg)

Introduction

A couple of months ago ATI launched their Radeon 5870, the world’s first DirectX11 graphics card to great critical acclaim. Shortly after this they brought to market two great mainstream cards in the form of the 5750 and 5770 which gave us price and performance similar to the older 4800 series but with additional/enhanced features, lower temperatures and more desirable power requirements.

With those products ATI have a very impressive set of high end and mainstream cards which currently have no direct competition from Nvidia due to their delay in getting DX11 products to market. This may change shortly but in the mean time ATI are now making an attempt to take a stranglehold on the enthusiast market with the release of their high end Radeon 5970.

Today we will be taking a look at the Powercolor HD 5970 2GB and putting it through its paces in a selection of real world gaming tests, including the recently released Modern Warfare 2. In addition to this we will cover GPU computing and high definition playback as well as having a play with an official ATI voltage tweaking tool. This little application may well make this product a favourite with enthusiasts who want to get the most from their purchase.

Powercolor Radeon HD 5970 2GB

(http://i46.tinypic.com/24d4fgn.jpg) (http://i46.tinypic.com/dc6c1j.jpg)

(http://i49.tinypic.com/2na2n4j.jpg)

ATI are stepping away from their traditional naming conventions with this product. In the past this would have been called the “5870 X2” but not this time, instead we have the 5970.

The reason the card would have had the X2 branding is that this is a dual GPU model, something which is rather obvious when looking at it! This really is a monster card which is just under twelve inches long and externally it is similar to the other high end 5000 series. Turning the card around we see that the back of the PCB is covered by the same black cover which was also present on the 5800’s though this has the space for two GPU X-clamps.

The card comes with a voucher for Dirt 2 when it is released next month and there is also a Crossfire connector, video adapter, 8 pin to 6 pin power convertor and a minidisplayport to HDMI adapter ... a great selection of cables from Powercolor.

(http://i50.tinypic.com/n6vvhe.jpg) (http://i50.tinypic.com/2vmiz2w.jpg)

(http://i49.tinypic.com/ir2xkz.jpg) (http://i48.tinypic.com/kcfcev.jpg)

The rest of the 5000 series have native dual DVIs, HDMI and DisplayPort but the 5970 is a little different. It still has two dual-link DVIs but the third output is a mini DisplayPort. What this allows ATI to do is a have a full height exhaust section, something which is beneficial on a card which produces a lot of heat from its two GPUs. HDMI is still possible via a convertor but it looks like native support was not important to ATI on a model which isn’t really aimed at HTPCs. As with the rest of the 5000 series we are able to connect three 2560x1600 screens to this card at any one time.

Looking at the top edge of the product we can see the two power inputs, six and eight pin connectors. Further along is a single CrossFireX connector which can be used to connect another 5890, 5870 or 5850. Also worth noting is that there are a large number of vents along the top of the heatsink shroud which were not present on the single GPU models.

(http://i50.tinypic.com/2lbpbgy.jpg) (http://i49.tinypic.com/2ily2z5.jpg)

ATI apply a large Vapor chamber heatsink to the dual GPU’s which is designed to cool up to 400w and passing air across it is a ‘famous’ red ATI fan, similar in design to the one used on most high end ATI cards. It is good to see a vapor chamber cooler on a reference card and the impressive components continue with the inclusion of multi-point programmable fan controller (SMSC EMC2103), digital programmable voltage regulators and Japanese ceramic capacitors.

(http://i50.tinypic.com/2lbndl3.jpg) (http://i45.tinypic.com/1z3s178.jpg) (http://i50.tinypic.com/iwhweu.jpg)

For the main specifications of the card, other than the second generation PLX PCIe 2.0 bridge we have a real mix of 5870 and 5850. This card uses the core and memory speeds of the 5850 which are 725MHz core and 1000MHz on the 2GB of Hynix GDDR5 (1Gb per 40nm GPU). From the 5870 specification we get 1600 stream processors per GPU. The ROP count and memory bus of 256bit was the same as the 5870 and 5850 so it is no surprise to see the same bus here along with 2x32 ROPs. Texture units are taken from the 5870 however which means we have 80 per GPU.

When fully loaded the 5970 has a power rating of 294 watts which compares well with the 5850s 170w and the 188w drawn by the 5870. Idle board power is very impressive using a maximum of 42w ... well below 2x the 5800s which were both 27w.

As stated earlier this card supports DirectX 11 and as a result this means Shader Model 5 and ComputeShader/DirectCompute 11. Additionally like other recent cards the 5970 supports PCI-Express 2 and as well as Blu-Ray acceleration via ATI Avivo.

Radeon HD 5970 Features

On the last pages we looked at the 5970 hardware configuration, now it is time to take a look at the features that consumers will use on a daily basis.

Shader Model 5

Shader Model 5 provides a new instruction set with an architecture which is unified across all shader types (Vertex, Hull, Domain, Geometry, Pixel and Compute). The new instructions add features which benefit end users as well as developers. For example SV_Coverage provides edge detection for optimised anti-aliasing and Flexible Gather gives us faster shadow filtering and ambient occlusion.

DirectCompute 11

DirectCompute 11 is one of the major features in DirectX 11 and the Radeon 5970, it applies to gaming/productivity and enhances the performance of both. In productivity related scenarios it allows the GPU to perform processing of items such as video effects. Using Cyberlink’s PowerDirector 8 as an example we can apply effects such as Radial Blur with the processing completing significantly faster than the CPU alone.

In a gaming scenario the system is able to better use multiple cores on CPUs to enhance Physics and AI but visual improvements are also present. One example is Order Independent Transparency. Using ATI’s Mesh demo as an example, the traditional Alpha Blending and sorting performed when rendering the item requires multiple passes, 64 in this case. When DirectCompute 11 is applied the operation can be completed in a single pass with perfect results.

(http://i45.tinypic.com/24b21xg.jpg)

Tessellation

Through use of two new shaders (Hull and Domain) included in Shader Model 5/DirectX11 the 5970 includes improved Tessellation. Through use of this improved tessellation games have the potential to include characters, objects, clothes and terrain with additional detail. Essentially the GPU can break up the scene into a huge number of sections, far more than is easy to process in DirectX 10 and with every section the level of detail increases. The following example shows the two approaches.


DirectX 10/DirectX 11
(http://i46.tinypic.com/2eun8ls.jpg) (http://i50.tinypic.com/2edp6za.jpg)

(http://i47.tinypic.com/25k7d.jpg) (http://i47.tinypic.com/14y7keu.jpg)

Render Post-Processing

High Definition Ambient Occlusion and contact hardened shadows are two features which we should also see making their way into games, in fact EA’s BattleForge already uses the former though the effects are very subtle in that engine. HDAO looks at the geometry of a scene and darkens areas dependant on their depth. CHS sharpens edges at the contact point with the object casting the shadow and makes them increasingly blurry as they fade into the distance.

New anisotropic filtering algorithm and render back end.

As with the release of previous generations ATI has put effort into optimising the display quality of their new hardware. For the 5970 series this means the implementation of a new AF algorithm which eliminates angle dependence with no performance impact. For anti-aliasing the redesigned render back end reduces the performance hit when applying the various levels of anti-aliasing.

For those interested in the display quality of the ATI card, here is a scene from World in Conflict Soviet Assault which was captured at 2560x1600 with 4x anti-aliasing, 16x anisotropic filtering and maximum ingame detail.

Nvidia/ATI
(http://i50.tinypic.com/2hreomg.jpg) (http://i46.tinypic.com/hurf3s.jpg)

HD Playback

The 5970 series of GPUs use an enhanced version of the ATI Unified Video Decoder, this new version can decode dual 1080p HD video streams. ATI have also improved the configuration options within the Avivo section of CCC to include Video Gamma which is independent from the desktop setting, blue stretch processing for brighter colours and configurable dynamic video range.

In addition to this Blu-Ray playback with Windows Aero enabled has been implemented in Windows 7.

Eyefinity

Both the 5800 and 5700 support three displays at 2560x1600 however this may not be enough for some people and as a result ATI will launch the Eyefinity version of the 5870. The Eyefinity Edition will support up to 6 DisplayPort monitors with a theoretical maximum resolution of 8192x8192 (67.1 Megapixel). For the 5970 cards the display configuration is 2x dual-link DVI and a single DisplayPort giving a maximum resolution of 7680x1600.

(http://i50.tinypic.com/1z68p6b.jpg)

(http://i48.tinypic.com/2uetdo3.jpg)

The test system was built from scratch, a format of the hard drive was performed (NTFS) and then Windows 7 was installed. Following the completion of the installation, the video drivers were installed. All windows updates were then installed as were the latest builds of the benchmarking tools. Finally, the hard drives were de-fragmented. For each test, the video drivers were set to default quality/optimizations (unless otherwise stated).

Good Benchmarking Practice

Where possible, each benchmark was performed three times and the median result for each resolution/setting is shown in the tables that will follow. All applications had their latest patches applied and all hardware features the latest BIOS/Firmware.

DriverHeaven does not use benchmark scripts. We play the games for long periods of time on various levels and report any unusual findings we see. Then we record with FRAPS across several in game levels recording the averages. This is real world testing and is just how you guys will experience the game. These results give the reader balanced and directly comparable set of figures for comparing cards.

One of the most important aspects of enjoying a game is minimum frame rates which can have the greatest impact on the gaming experience. Due to this we also include a separate graph which details the framerates every second during a level for each of the tested games. This framerate graph allows us to show you how stable the framerates are in on a product and how often they rise towards the maximum or fall to the minimum level. We have also incorporated a 'red line' at the 25 frame per second mark to show the 'cut off' point that most people find acceptable - if you see the current frame rate line drop below this then you can expect the game to become choppy.

Essentially it gives a good representation of the experience you will have when playing. For these tests we focus on a worst case scenario, the most demanding section of game that we can find.

NOTE: As the expanded framerate graph is based on a single run of real world gameplay before we take into account multiple results there can be some variation between identical cards. We make every effort to keep the test as repeatable as possible however with advancements in game technology identical single results are often impossible.

(http://i49.tinypic.com/1zyu8ux.jpg)
(http://i49.tinypic.com/2whnjme.jpg)

EA’s BattleForge was one of a few games which supported DirectX 10.1 when using Radeon 4000 series hardware. Now, on the 5000 series, it and STALKER Call of Pripyat the only games currently available with DirectX 11 support.

Support for DirectX 11 and technologies such as High Definition Screen Occlusion, Shader Model 5 and Compute Shader were added to the game in September. By default the game will use Shader Model 5/DX11 rendering on the 5000 series, it can also be forced by editing the configuration file. HDAO can be enabled by setting the SSAO option to very high in the game menu; on the 5000s this also enables ComputeShader. Like the DirectX 10.1 implementation on BattleForge the DX11 features are all aimed at improving performance, this is not a title which benefits from a large difference in visuals between modes.

The first thing worth noting about these results is that the 5890 gives us performance which, even when at its lowest of 46fps, is above the highest possible on two 4870s in CrossFireX. The 5890 is also a significant amount faster than the 5870 which indicates that CrossFire is working well in this title which clearly is not a priority for Nvidia’s driver team.

Although the performance is great on the 5970 there is one issue, the game has a minor bug at our tested settings which results in textures briefly disappearing when zooming in and out. It doesn’t make the game unplayable or any less enjoyable but it is noticeable.

(http://i46.tinypic.com/2hwfckm.jpg)
(http://i48.tinypic.com/15znhur.jpg)
(http://i48.tinypic.com/29123hd.jpg)
(http://i45.tinypic.com/1z4g9xk.jpg)

When launching H.A.W.X. we are given the opportunity of running in DirectX 9 or 10 mode, then within the DirectX 10 version of the game Radeon hardware allows us to enable DirectX 10.1 for enhanced performance.

In BattleForge we saw a small bug when running the game on the 5000 series, in HAWX it is the Nvidia based system which gives us issues. When selecting 1920x1200 the game was unstable with 8x anti-aliasing applied but we were able to complete enough tests to include results. When using 2560x1600 with the same anti-aliasing level it was not possible to pass the main menu (which uses the game engine) and due to this there are no statistics above for that particular result on the 295. Hopefully this will be fixed in a future driver revision because the performance at 1920x1200 was good with the minimum fps coming close to the 5870. ATI’s new 5970 is the performance leader though, CrossFire works well in this game and we see large increases over the 5870 and a completely different league of performance to the 4870 multi-GPU setup.

(http://i46.tinypic.com/2wqaeya.jpg)
(http://i47.tinypic.com/25ew8jq.jpg)
(http://i45.tinypic.com/ms2e82.jpg)
(http://i48.tinypic.com/2q16o2v.jpg)

When testing Modern Warfare 2 there are some fantastic framerates created by the 5970 at 1920x1200, several times it peaks over 300fps and once over 400fps. There are also some impressive peaks at 2560x1600 with 4xAA however the shine is taken off the results a little by the fact some work is needed on the driver.

During some heavy post processing effects in our test the framerate drops below 25fps on a couple of occasions. The game is still completely playable when in normal gameplay but it will be good to see this issue ironed out in a future driver as 2560x1600 with 4aa is pretty much as good as it gets with Modern Warfare 2.
(http://i48.tinypic.com/11rero8.jpg)
(http://i50.tinypic.com/bdtpnq.jpg)
(http://i46.tinypic.com/xdilus.jpg)

Need For Speed Shift is another game which forces us to talk about driver bugs. On the Nvidia side it was some very odd performance and flashing texture issues at 1920x1200 which made the game unplayable as well as lag problems at 2560x1600. ATI on the other hand just have random performance issues with framerates all over the place though thankfully the game does not suffer from the same lag experienced on the GTX 295. We look forward to the upcoming game patch which should resolve many of these issues because when it works Shift is a lot of fun to play and looks great.

(http://i49.tinypic.com/mslyd2.jpg)
(http://i45.tinypic.com/152cqqb.jpg)
(http://i46.tinypic.com/152lr82.jpg)

Under normal circumstances our method of testing would see each card tested at the maximum available settings for the lowest specification card in the test. The reason for this is that GTA IV places limits on the image quality available depending on the specifications of the system and to show comparable results we had to match with the lowest available results. This was initially quite helpful as these limits reduced crashes when the game was launched in a buggy state. As it has matured the need for these limitations is no longer present and so we configure it to allow maximum detail on all of the cards.

With maximum detail applied and the resolution set to 2560x1600 we see that this is a game where the 5970 shows it brute force. The CrossFire scaling in this game is not great but we still achieve framerates which are above 25fps and for the majority of our test it was 30fps or above.
(http://i49.tinypic.com/34e5e9y.jpg)
(http://i47.tinypic.com/2hp4029.jpg)

Left 4 Dead uses Valve’s Source engine. This is the same engine which will be used in one of this year’s most anticipated games... Left 4 Dead 2 which is released later this week. For this reason it is useful to see how all of these cards handle the original game.

Left 4 Dead is another game where we see a huge performance difference between two of ATI’s last generation GPUs and two of the latest. On the dual GPU 4870 system the maximum framerate is only 10% higher than the average performance of the 5970. CrossFire scaling is also working quite well in this title with the 5970 outperforming the higher clocked 5870 by 63fps on average, though the minimum performance could do with a little optimisation.

(http://i48.tinypic.com/jb5uyv.jpg)
(http://i46.tinypic.com/2w2q91v.jpg)
(http://i48.tinypic.com/1znyeqa.jpg)
(http://i48.tinypic.com/jjocd5.jpg)

Borderlands is a game which uses Epic’s Unreal Engine V3. This engine is also used on titles such as Unreal Tournament 3, Batman Arkham Asylum and Gears of War so is a useful game to see the performance figures for.

The first noticeable aspect of the results is the lack of figures for the 4870 based system. The reason for this is that the game froze when jumping into any save game and as a result there was no way to gather repeatable, comparable performance figures.

For the other cards we see that this is a game/engine which suits the GTX 295 at settings up to 1920x1200 where it outperforms the 5970 on average framerates. When we move to 2560x1600 the GTX 295 suffers from a larger drop in performance than the 5870/5970 which gives us perfectly playable framerates throughout our testing.

Title: Re: Close Up Look At The Radeon 5870 Part 1
Post by: javajolt on November 19, 2009, 02:42:11 AM
(http://i47.tinypic.com/f27h8z.jpg)
Title: Re: Close Up Look At The Radeon 5870 Part 1
Post by: javajolt on November 19, 2009, 07:43:18 AM

The next meeting we have I will bring it up.  Hope your laptop recovers soon.
Title: Re: Close Up Look At The Radeon 5870 Part 1
Post by: Jake on November 19, 2009, 10:01:31 PM
It's running fine, just had to disable images so I could access this thread to post.